Searching for the perfect pizza doesnâ€™t limit me to traditional restaurants and pizzerias. Iâ€™m not even limited to traditional bars and pubs that serve it. So when friends recommended pizza at Shaker's Cigar Bar, known more for its haunted tours than food or even cigars, I had to give the pie a try.
The website for Shaker's Cigar Bar includes enough articles to provide much of the information I try to learn about a business, including a couple featured right here at OnMilwaukee. Current owner and chef Bob Weiss opened Shakers, 422 S. 2nd St., in 1986.
Weiss inherited a building that came with "guests," leading to stories and testimonies from customers that landed Shaker's on lists for most haunted bars in America. People pay to go on haunted tours, and some will pay to spend the night on the third floor, hoping to have an encounter with a ghost. I think itâ€™s cool that Shaker's brings more publicity to Milwaukee.
Weiss owned several smoke shops, but closed them after cigars seemed to lose popularity. He affiliated cigars with "big-ticket" experiences and sought to provide a premium experience with Shaker's, which explains the visit I had with some of my Yelp friends a few weeks ago on a Monday night.
I reviewed the menu online before I visited to get a feel for what I might want to try and also to give my friends an idea of what to expect.
The menu tends to change monthly and is small, which is wise considering the kitchen is right behind the bar and doesnâ€™t allow for much flexibility. The June menu featured a handful of appetizers, including Moroccan hummus and larb, which I was very surprised to see on the menu. Larb is a staple in Laotian cuisine, typically very spicy, flavorful and made with ground chicken or beef. I donâ€™t even find the dish on most Southeast Asian menus in town, so Iâ€™d never expect to see it at a cigar bar. The small list of entrees shared a theme and featured Cajun flavors with andouille etouffee, bayou jambalaya and cajun garlic shrimp.
The appetizers ranged from $5.50 to $12.50, and the main dishes ranged from $7.50 to $28.50 for the cajun garlic shrimp (all reasonable prices), which is why I was very surprised to see pizzas ranging from $16.50 for a 10-inch pizza with meat toppings to $42.40 for a 14-inch "Shrimp-o-Rama" pizza. Yes, $42.50 for a 14-inch pizza. The average 14-inch pizza was $28.50.
The friends who referred me said the pizza was some of the best theyâ€™ve tasted, so my expectations were very high after seeing those prices.
The weather was perfect, so we sat out on the patio: a platform covering part of 2nd Street and enclosed by railings (to prevent diners from falling off their chairs and into the street, I suspect). We placed our orders and waited with anticipation for what was to come. There were six of us, so we ordered the Moroccan hummus and bruschetta con pomodoro y mozzarella to start, followed by three 14-inch pizzas.
We could see into the kitchen through the window from our table on the patio, which helped me get some of my usual questions answered about how the pizzas are made. I panicked when I saw a clear, plastic bag come out of a small refrigerator filled with discs that looked like pizza crusts. Then I saw the cook cut the discs into strips, and I figured the discs must have been large pita or naan for our hummus. I calmed back down.
The hummus and bruschetta arrived, and both were beautifully plated. Toasted baguette slices topped with freshly diced tomatoes sat on a bed of baked cheese, and balsamic vinegar was drizzled carefully over the entire platter. The hummus arrived in the center of a platter surrounded by the strips of baked flat bread. They had a cracker texture and were slightly bitter and very dry from being over-baked, and we all thought the hummus was pretty bland. The bruschetta was the better dish of the two, by far. I would recommend it if the same version is on the menu.
While eating our appetizers, I looked through the window again to watch for the pizza-making process. Again I saw the plastic bag come out of the refrigerator. The dry and bitter cracker-like strips served with our hummus were cut from pre-made pizza crusts, after all. I asked if they were made by a local baker; but the source turned out to be Restaurant Depot.
At this point, I feel I should remind all seven of you reading this that my pizza blog contains my opinions only and not those of the owners, management or staff at OnMilwaukee. Now Iâ€™m going to step onto my soap box.
Look, I donâ€™t have a problem with a business using pre-made pizza crusts. There are pizzerias all over town using pre-made frozen or refrigerated crusts, and Iâ€™ve blogged about a few of them here. Kitchen space, lack of proper equipment and city ordinances limit what some restaurants and pizzerias can do, so pre-made crusts from a supplier are necessary for a business at times, and Iâ€™m fine with that.
However, those pizzerias price their finished products accordingly. There are a couple of other pizza places in town that charge $25 to $30 for a 14- or 16-inch pizza, but they have more than two basic toppings on them, and I know that they donâ€™t use pre-made crusts because Iâ€™ve visited and inquired. If the two toppings are filet mignon and truffles, then Iâ€™ll pay $30 or more for the pizza, but not for sausage and pepperoni. I can find better options in town for half the price.
Also, I think if a venue wishes to give its customers a perception that they are paying for premium food, drinks and a high-end overall experience, I donâ€™t believe a bag of pre-made pizza crusts sends that message. Although to be fair, I didnâ€™t see those crusts made. The bottom line is that if the crust comes from Restaurant Depot, how can I trust the quality of the other ingredients that, I assume, are intended to justify a $28 pizza? Iâ€™ll step off my soap box now and tell you about the pizzas we ordered.
The pizzas are available on 10- and 14-inch thin crusts. We ordered three 14-inchers: the Basil Chicken, the Redondo, and a sausage and pepperoni pizza. Each was $28.50. Shakers has two stacked pizza ovens, and only one other table had diners, so all three of our pizzas arrived at the same time, and all three were cut into pie slices.
I started into the sausage and pepperoni pizza. The crust was crisp around the edge, but the pizza was cut into pie slices, so when I picked up a slice, it flopped. The slices were cut too narrow to fold in half "New York style," so I used two hands until I ate the first third of the slice and could hold it with one hand without it collapsing. The flavors were solid, but I thought the crust was a bit too dry. I liked the slightly spicy sauce, as well as the slightly spicy sausage and pepperoni.
Next up was the Redondo, which is listed as their most popular pizza and topped with Wisconsin goat cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, sweet caramelized red onions, citrus marinated artichokes, sweet roasted red peppers, house made pesto (according to the menu), oregano, and freshly chopped basil. I didnâ€™t see any basil, but there was plenty on this pizza, so I didnâ€™t care.
A couple of my friends grabbed a slice, but one of them noticed a strand of hair on the slice she was about to grab. She thought it might have been her own, so she went to remove it except when she did, it lifted the cheese and artichoke. It wasnâ€™t her hair. We looked at the cookâ€™s hair and determined it definitely wasnâ€™t his either, so the hair likely got into the cheese or other topping storage container during prep. I didnâ€™t bother asking if the hair was a premium topping, as well. I took the pizza back, and the bartender/server apologized, had another one made and took this pizza off the bill.
On that note, I want to acknowledge the outstanding service we received from our bartender/server, Jeff. He was very attentive, while playing the role of bartender and waiter and having customers inside the bar and outside on the patio. I think he did everything right and definitely impressed me, as well as my friends. He really helped salvage the experience.
We worked on the basil chicken pizza while we waited for the Redondo re-fire. The menu describes it simply as "fresh sweet basil tossed and rubbed chicken breast over mounds of mozzarella and fresh tomatoes and basil." The chicken was tender, and I really enjoyed the overall flavor combinations. Again, the pizza was cut into pie slices, so the crust was crisp at the edge but flopped in the center.
When the new hair-free Redondo pizza arrived, we dove in and, once more, I was pleased with the flavors and textures of the toppings. Normally I donâ€™t like the texture of artichokes on my pizza, but these were cut small enough to be balanced with the red peppers and sun-dried tomatoes. I could also taste the pesto, even though there was a base of red pizza sauce, so overall the pizza had a nice balance of flavors.
Other specialty pizzas that intrigued us included the Artiste with broccoli, cauliflower, marinated eggplant, mozzarella, Greek yogurt, blue cheese, basil, oregano and sesame seeds, as well as the Bernice, which is topped with sausage, pepperoni, caramelized onions, mushrooms, and black olives. The menu states that Bernice died there in 2008, and you should ask for her story.
Overall, I was glad that I satisfied my curiosity about the pizza at Shaker's, both after friends endorsed it and after Shaker's claimed on Facebook to have the best pizza in the city under the Milwaukee Restaurant Row alias. Iâ€™m also grateful that I have friends who are willing to trying new dining experiences and save me a few bucks in the process.
I think the toppings on the pizzas listed on the menu are well thought out. The flavor combinations I tasted seemed to work, but I think the crust can be improved. Some of the pizzas might be worth close to $28.50, but I recommend passing on a basic two-topping pizza if you decide to give Shaker's pizza a try and go with one of the more elaborate pies to improve your odds in the value game. Then again, you could just skip the menu, order a drink, light up a cigar and take a haunted tour to add your own story to the lore.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Rick Rodriguez
Published Feb. 9, 2020
Happy National Pizza Day! Our neighborhoods are filled with pizzerias - all unique, bursting with flavor and filled with storied histories. One Milwaukeean has eaten his way through the lion's share. His hard work translates into your guide to great pizza in greater Milwaukee.
Published April 15, 2019
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana was under construction when Rick Rodriguez retired his blog "In search of the perfect pizza," but he vowed to come back and write one last blog about Milwaukee's first and only certified Neapolitan pizzeria.
Published Oct. 11, 2016
Rick Rodriguez has been blogging about his search for the perfect pizza for four years. Now that he's retiring from his post, he shares some favorite spots from the past few years as well as parting words for readers who've followed his adventure.
Published Sept. 7, 2016
In his 100th pizza blog, Rick ventures out to Waukesha where, upon the recommendation of a friend or two, he tries pizza, garlic cheese bread and ponza rottas from Jimmy's Grotto. What's a ponza rotta? Well, you'll have to read to find out.
Published Aug. 3, 2016
Rick Rodriguez says he doesn't think he's ever written about a pizza place as new as Fixture Pizza Pub. In this installment of his pizza blog, he gives the lowdown on the space, the food and a few other interesting facts about the owners and offerings.
Published July 15, 2016
Rick Rodriguez is often asked "who makes the best pizza?" or "who makes your favorite pizza?" The latter is a difficult question to answer, and the former is nearly impossible to answer. Still, here are some his top picks for Milwaukee pizza.
Published June 1, 2016
Despite a sizable menu that includes hand-tossed pizzas, pizza blogger Rick Rodriguez dings Zayna's Pizza for the dense crust and a Mexican pizza on which the toppings "could use a little tweaking."
Published May 4, 2016
The folks at Carini's La Conca D'Oro have a long and storied history, with roots in Italy. They serve up authentic Neapolitan pizza, along with other Italian dishes including a variety of seafood entrees.
Published April 6, 2016
It's not often Rick Rodriguez writes about reader-selected spots. But the words "thin crust," "good pizza" and "small bar" were repeated by enough people that he felt a visit to Scotty's was warranted.
Published March 2, 2016
In addition to pizza, Albanese's offers a slew of specials, including wings, Sicilian style pork chops and Italian style fish fry on Fridays. They also happen to have gluten free pizza that's worth seeking out.