Marty's Pizza certainly does not cheat you when it comes to the toppings.
Marty's Pizza certainly does not cheat you when it comes to the toppings.
Marty's opened back in 1957 and now has two locations, one in Brookfield and the other in Delafield.
Marty's opened back in 1957 and now has two locations, one in Brookfield and the other in Delafield.

In search of the perfect pizza: Marty's Pizza

For the seventh straight year, October is Dining Month on OnMilwaukee.com, presented by the restaurants of Potawatomi. All month, we're stuffed with restaurant reviews, delectable features, chef profiles and unique articles on everything food, as well as the winners of our "Best of Dining 2013."

I was first introduced to Marty’s Pizza, 16680 W. Bluemound Rd., when I worked in Brookfield. Sales or training meetings often featured Marty’s party pizzas for lunch.

Back in 1980, Edward Bautz bought the pizzeria from Marty and Angie Skibosh, who started the company in 1957. Bautz opened a second location in Delafield in 1989 and now co-owns it with his son-in-law, Richard Flath, who runs the Delafield location, found at 2580 Sun Valley Dr.

I dined at the Brookfield location on a recent Thursday night. The main dining room was filled with dark wooden tables and booths teamed with red vinyl chairs and benches.

They seemed busy when I arrived. All of the booths were occupied, as well as several tables. One family was celebrating a little girl’s birthday, and customers entered regularly for their carry-out orders.

I’m not sure how much delivery business Marty's does, but the phone rang often, and the back of the restaurant boasted a fleet of at least 10 small trucks for deliveries and catering.

When I’m in the Brookfield area on business, the Marty’s delivery trucks are almost as common on the road as the FedEx or UPS trucks.

Marty’s menu includes pizza, pasta, subs, salads, wings, appetizers and burgers. For catering, Marty’s can prepare various salads, pasta, sandwich, veggie, cheese and beef trays.

Marty’s pizzas are different from most in that they’re all made into square or rectangular pies, as opposed to the more common round pizzas. The dough is made fresh daily, and crust comes in one style: thin and crispy. 

Pie sizes start with a 10-inch square small and grow to a 14-inch by 5-foot long Super Colossal pizza. I didn’t make that up. Cheese pizzas run from $8.95 to $53.20 for the Super Colossal, which sounds about right.

Seven-inch individual pizzas are $4.95 with additional toppings for 50 cents each, and a 10-inch gluten-free round crust is now available.

Specialty pizzas start at $10.55 and include a chicken club, bacon cheeseburger, taco pizza, meatball mozzarella, spinach and chicken alfredo, barbecue chicken, Hawaiian, bacon and egg, and a chicken broccoli alfredo.

The pizza section tells diners to expect 25 to 30 minutes for their pizza to cook, which I think is a good way to try and prevent customers from whining waiting for their orders. I also think it sends a subtle recommendation to start with an appetizer.

On my visit, I chose the sausage, pepperoni and meatball pizza, and played with my smartphone to pass the time. I was pretty hungry, so when my pizza arrived, it took some willpower to hold off on eating it until I snapped a few photos.

The slices around the perimeter had the cracker crunch that I crave in a pizza crust. The center slices were a little softer, but still slightly crisp and held the heavy toppings well. I was also pleased that there were no traces of cornmeal on the crust.

Marty’s gets its Italian sausage from a local supplier using a recipe originated by Skibosh. The large chunks of sausage are not very spicy but offer a great flavor.

The pepperoni is a bit zesty, but the meatballs seemed to have the hottest flavor, along with an array of flavors from Marty’s seasoning blend.

The meatballs are made in house and sliced in half before being generously applied. In fact, all of the toppings were generously applied. When my pizza arrived, I stared at it for a minute to think of what I wanted the photos to showcase, the crust or the large meat toppings.

Biting into each slice left delightful traces of the thick sauce on both sides of my mouth, which some of you know is how I determine if the right amount of sauce was applied. The sauce was a little spicy, but I was also picking up a subtle sweetness to it.

Several years had passed since my prior Marty’s Pizza experience, but some good memories returned after this refresher.

I don’t think I’ve ever tried any other menu items, but I learned that Wednesdays and Thursdays feature an all-you-can-eat pasta special, with your choice of spaghetti or mostaccioli with meatballs or meat sauce, and garlic bread for only $6.99.

As I scanned the dining room, it seemed the diners were fairly split between the pasta special and the pizza. I wouldn’t mind going back to give the pasta a try.

I might also head out to the Delafield location. I’m told Flath uses a different recipe for the sauce on those pizzas. I don’t get to Delafield often, but I am intrigued. Have you tried it?

Talkbacks

Post your comment/review now No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now

Facebook comments

Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.