Later this week, I will publish an article on OnMilwaukee.com about interesting alcoholic beverages made with soft drinks.
Researching this article topic reminded me that I have unsuccessfully tried to identify the invisible geographical dividing lines that demarcate where people say "pop" and others say "soda." I can't figure it out.
I have friends from northern and southern Wisconsin who say "pop," whereas I, who grew up in Milwaukee, have never called sugary carbonated beverages anything but "soda."
Is there a line zigzagging across Wisconsin that divides the pop drinkers from the soda drinkers?
It gets even more complicated when I try to figure out where the pop / soda boundaries exist across the entire country. I have friends from Minnesota, Illinois and California who say "pop" and friends from other parts of Illinois and California who say, "soda." And then there's my friend from Florida who calls everything "Coke" and my Kentucky-born father who called it "soda pop."
Any idea how or why these terms vary so much, particularly in Wisconsin? And are we in agreement that "soda" is the most widely used term for soft drinks here in Milwaukee?
Duh peeps; it's carbonated soft drink and a "bubbler" is a drinking fountain. Water fountains are usually very massive and in parks; kids pee in them and adults toss change in them. Soda is for cooking or icky tummies; and pop is an action verb.
Who really cares. It has been debated for decades along with other regional dialects and nicknames. My mail-ordered Canadian wife calls it pop, while I (a long time Wisconsinite) call it "Coke" so that I am not labeled as said Wisconsinite.
jimg | Aug. 24, 2011 at 4:53 p.m. (report)
I grew up in Michigan and called everything pop. I understood (at least in MI) it derived from the Faygo brand. One of their best selling flavors was Redpop, which Michiganders just shortened to Pop and assigned to everything.
I moved to Milwaukee in 1969 from Lincoln, Nebraska, where we drank pop. The only soda I knew was for baking (in the little yellow box) or for that other kind of drinking, as in "scotch and soda."
I grew up in Minneapolis before College in Wisconsin and never could understand this quirk. In MN, 100% of the time, you asked for a "Pop".
My take on it was that my home state was MinnesoTa and you never pronounced it MinnesoDa. Doesn't explain that National map much but I always stood by my take on it.
So I was always called out as being a 'foreigner' whenever I ordered a "Pop" here out of habit. Fully shamed, I changed my order to PBRs and fell right in.
I grew up in Northeast WI and we always had pop. I had my first soda when I moved to Milwaukee in 1980. My Dad had sodapop made at a soda shop.
Show me the other 10 Talkbacks
15 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Molly Snyder
Published Sept. 20, 2019
For some patios, the season is almost over, but Steny's can now keep theirs open 365 days a year.
Published Sept. 20, 2019
Stop by Muse Brews at the Newaukee Night Market on Wednesday, Sept. 11. for a sample of kombucha and decide for yourself if it's a go or a no.
Published Sept. 19, 2019
This weekend, OnMilwaukee posted a story about the Captain's Steak Joynt chains that were around Milwaukee and the state in the 1970s and `80s. Numerous people commented via Facebook that they remembered and loved the cheese fondue that was a staple at the Captain's salad bar. Here's the recipe.
Published Sept. 18, 2019
Like podcasts? Here's a fresh, new one that digs deep but stays light while unearthing issues that nobody else is talking about. Like ways a "normal couple" can practice non-monogamy.
Published Sept. 16, 2019
Stack'd Burger bar is stoked to have provided a decade of service to Milwaukee and in appreciation offers flashback prices and extended happy hour specials.
Published Sept. 14, 2019
Hard seltzer is hot hot hot, but some of us are still smitten with plain ol' LaCroix.
Published Sept. 13, 2019
You've seen dogs on patios, but how about Barnes and Noble or any of these other places you'd never suspect are dog-friendly?
Published Sept. 9, 2019
When Adia Green and her two sons participate in the 2019 Greater Milwaukee Heart & Stroke Walk/5K Run later this month, they'll celebrate not one but two of their family members' lives.
Published Sept. 9, 2019
Fallen officer Matthew Ritnner's name will soon be added to the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Wall in D.C. and to contribute to travel expenses for Rittner's family and cow-workers, Uncle Buck's will host a fundraiser during the Packers game.
Published Sept. 6, 2019
It's been a few years since Milwaukee had a locally-based cloth diaper service, but as of the end of August, the option returned when Abigail Austin launched Wholesome Diaper Co.