Thank you, Mr. Lightfoot.
There was a time that I needed Gordon Lightfootâ€™s music. Something about the words and melodies resonated with me emotionally. I used to play his songs over and over again during a time that I needed them, and theyâ€™d always pull me out of whatever was on my mind. The melodies connected with me as I fell asleep to them; the lyrics spoke to me. But thatâ€™s what great music does.
So, it was a privilege to hear the great Canadian songwriter and folk rock singer (arguably the country's best ever)Â take the stage at The Pabst Theater on Wednesday in Milwaukee.
It was fitting that Lightfoot was in Wisconsin in November. If you donâ€™t get that reference, then you donâ€™t remember the words of the iconic Lightfoot song, "Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald," which stands at the heart of his catalogue: "That good ship and crew was a bone to be chewed, when the gales of November came early. The ship was the pride of the American side, coming back from some mill in Wisconsin." Few songwriters have done better to capture the soul of the Great Lakes region and its people.
It turns out, though, that the "witch of November" is age. Thereâ€™s something rather insidious about the way that age zeroes in on a personâ€™s greatest gifts. Other than the iconic few, where the lyrics are so well-known that the audience could and did (somewhat) sing along, many of the songs Lightfoot performed on Wednesday were, if we are brutally honest, hard to distinguish from one another anymore.
Thatâ€™s what happens when itâ€™s tough to discern the lyrics because of the softness of the performance. Lightfootâ€™s greatness rests in his melodies, sure. But it has really always rested in his writing. His songs tell stories that capture the spirit of a lost ship (and really its people and the places they came from) or they connect on an emotional level about subjects we all can understand (love, loss). Yet, this is also a man who, according to newspapers, was in a coma and learned how to replay guitar after a stroke stole the use of his fingers. And that was almost 10 years ago.
"Iâ€™m Gordon Lightfoot, and the rumors of my death are greatly exaggerated," Lightfoot told the packed hall at the Milwaukee concertâ€™s opening (indeed, in 2010, a Canadian radio station reported that heâ€™d died).
You donâ€™t go to see an almost 77-year-old, obviously frail and bone-thin musician, expecting to hear his songs sound like they did in his prime, though. You donâ€™t expect him to hop around like Mick Jagger. In fact, he barely moved from his spot in the center of the stage, although the straggly long hair and multiple guitars did harken to times past. If you really want to marvel at the poetry of the words, there are record albums, CDs and YouTube for that.
No, you go to play homage.
A younger relative I took along pointed out it was more akin to an Irish wake than a concert with the honoree alive in the room. Thatâ€™s an exaggeration, but it was, indeed, more about honoring the manâ€™s life and work with a few standing ovations and shout-outs ("We love you Gordon!") than anything else. It was about saying thank you.
It was about hearing Gordon Lightfoot just off the shore of Lake Michigan in November (although itâ€™s been a pretty nice November).
It was also about getting the chance to see an influential artist who helped define a genre (artist in every sense of the word; you wonâ€™t see this guy saying or doing things to shock) while you still can. There was a purity to his words. It was about hearing the words of songs you grew up with or needed sung live, perhaps for one of the last times, as even Lightfoot has commented that heâ€™s operating on borrowed time. It was about the slow passing of a generation.
Bob Dylan once famously said about Lightfootâ€™s songs that when he hears them he wishes they would last forever. And the greatness of the catalogue remained hard to deny. Lightfoot also showed flashes of long-ago swagger. "Meet me by the rock pile honey. Iâ€™m a lot bolder there," he said at one point.
Dylan was probably talking about songs like the unmistakable "Sundown," which probably had the most audience participation on Wednesday as the big radio hits came out one after the other starting at about the midpoint of the show. "Sheâ€™s been lookinâ€™ like a queen in a Sailorâ€™s Dream." And there was "Carefree Highway," singing, "Picking up the pieces of my sweet shattered dream, I wonder how the old folks are tonight."
Although that one passed pretty quickly â€“ and Lightfoot acknowledged that some of the songs were shortened â€“ you had to admire his stamina and determination to still sing them live. He strikes me as a man so wedded to his craft that he will never put down the guitar. And of course, there was "If You Could Read My Mind," singing, "If you could read my mind love, what a tale my thoughts could tell. Just like an old time movie, â€˜bout a ghost from a wishing well."
Lightfoot played "Fitzgerald" in about the middle of the show to rousing audience appreciation, singing, "The legend lives on from the Chippewa on downâ€¦"
The legend on Wednesday, though, was Lightfoot of course, who told the crowd he comes to Milwaukee every two years. Will he be back in another two? Hopefully. If he is, Iâ€™m going.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Jessica McBride
Published Aug. 13, 2016
A U.S. Magistrate judge's stunning decision overturning the Brendan Dassey conviction got Jessica McBride thinking. Will we see a Lawrencia Bembenek outcome here? And what does this decision mean for the still-imprisoned Steven Avery?
Published July 27, 2016
The Democratic National Convention has focused on a key argument: Our children are watching and listening, and what are they learning from Trump? However, watching the DNC Tuesday night, I couldn't help but think: What have our children learned from Bill Clinton?
Published July 20, 2016
It's astonishing when you think about it: a reality TV star who was only a joke a year ago became the Republican nominee this week. But how'd he pull it off? Here are the five key reasons why we are now truly looking at a potential President Trump.
Published July 13, 2016
The appointment of former Democratic state Attorney General Peg Lautenschlager to run the new Wisconsin Ethics Commission is hilarious - not only because of her past ethics board run-in, but because of the comical karma for Republicans.
Published July 7, 2016
Here's the thing: It's hard to read FBI Director James Comey's own comments on the Hillary Clinton email scandal and not believe that, had they really wanted to, the agency could have brought a case against the Democratic presidential nominee.
Published July 1, 2016
Three student journalists at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee spent a semester studying Milwaukee County's gun court, the court where non-fatal shootings are sent. What they found is crucial to further understanding the city's crime debate.
Published June 24, 2016
It's true that Omar Mateen's motives in Orlando may have been complicated, but here's why understanding the shooter's motives, and not editing his 911 calls, matters: Knowing the cause helps us craft solutions that are directly related to it.
Published June 22, 2016
Use of force, such as in a recent controversial Madison police arrest, is never a pretty sight. However, if you review standard police use-of-force continuums - as well as the full story - it's hard to see how this case merits the controversy.
Published June 15, 2016
So, Milwaukee has a new flag - at least unofficially. Will it make its way to becoming the official flag of the city? That we don't know yet, but we do know the new design reminds Jessica McBride of ... something. 11 somethings to be exact, listed here.
Published June 15, 2016
After the shooting in Orlando, the left rushed to blame guns and Republicans, while Donald Trump and the right rushed to blame the president. It seems that we have forgotten who the bad guy is here - and it's not each other.