I know I'm a grammar snob, but one word (which should be two), totally drives me crazy: when people who should know better spell "Bay View" as "Bayview."
I see it all the time: on the Actaea Works billboard on the corner of Oklahoma and Chase Avenues, on bumper stickers and on return addresses. Most disturbingly, it even graces the purple banners that hang from street lights in the neighborhood. Please tell whoever spell checked these things: Bay View is most definitely two words.
Come on. Is it too much to ask that you know how to spell the neighborhood in which you live? You don't see people splitting "River West," or mashing together "Elmgrove" or "Riverhills." Are people lazy or have they stopped caring all together?
Which brings up an even bigger pet peeve about my charming neighborhood, which I prefer to call "Milwaukee's Other East Side." Bay View isn't a city. That means addressing an envelope with "Bay View, WI 53207" is completely wrong. That's akin to writing your return address as "North Shore, WI 53217." Think about how snotty -- and ignorant -- that would look.
Bay View is a neighborhood, with rough and unofficial boundaries, in the City of Milwaukee. It used to be its own village, but was annexed by Milwaukee in 1887. I know Milwaukeeans don't like change, but I highly doubt even the most elderly business owners on Kinnickinnic Avenue, ordering business cards, are more than 120 years old.
I've heard a few reasons for people insisting that they live in "Bay View, Wis." and some seem innocuous enough. They cite neighborhood pride, and that's just fine, but then tell people you live in Bay View, but get your address right. You pay City of Milwaukee taxes, so you might as well know your correct mailing address.
The most nefarious excuse I've heard comes from people who don't want to associate their homes with the City of Milwaukee, because it's just a little too "urban." And if that's the case, it's just plain old racist and is simply despicable. Pretending you don't live in Milwaukee doesn't change anything, and truthfully, Bay View is one of the more diverse neighborhoods I've lived in (in Wisconsin, anyway).
So take pride, or don't -- that's up to you. But at least spell the name of your neighborhood correctly, Bay View. And don't forget that above and beyond all, this great community is part of the even greater City of Milwaukee.
Grammar snob or not, you owe it to yourself to know where you live.
AmyLCarson: do not cast aspersions on the linguistic skills of Christina Ward. She used to clean up the so-called English in novels to be published for a living. Guys who print up really big signs, on the other hand, aren't always so exacting ...
Not to mention guys who publish online magazines ...
Andy Tarnoff: "grammar" snobbery has nothing to do with it. This is not an issue of grammar, perhaps not even on of spelling, it's an issue of convention. For the record, I'm all for "Bay View," but if I'm going to hassle somebody about it, I'm at last going to characterize why I'm hassling them correctly.
But, for the record, if you send something to "Bay View, WI 53207" via USPS, it WILL be delivered there, so ...
On the other hand, "Kin-NIC-kin-nic" vs. "Kin-NI-kin-nic"--neither "c" is silent. UNLESS you live in Bay View, it seems. But we already have "TIE-tonia" and "New BER-lin," so ...
To OlderWiser: In regard to your question, Oak Creek, Greendale and Shorewood (plus Whitefish Bay, Fox Point and South Milwaukee) are not really Milwaukee. They are part of Milwaukee COUNTY, but each is its own CITY. MPS, MPD and MFD are city of Milwaukee departments. Shorewood has its own police department, fire department, etc., as does Greendale, Fox Point.
Make sense now?
Good work Winston. I have always wondered if it was acceptable to address like that. I see it done all the time. I will now start addressing my stuff like that. I like being able to differentiate my 'hood from the rest of the city.
winston | Nov. 9, 2007 at 8:35 a.m. (report)
You can search the usps website for acceptable City names associated with zip codes. For example a search of 53207 reveals:
Actual City name in 53207
Acceptable City names in 53207
BAY VIEW, WI
SAINT FRANCIS, WI
ST FRANCIS, WI
I'm not sure whose point this proves but it looks like our friendly post people have already debated this issue for us.
Show me the other 19 Talkbacks
24 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Andy Tarnoff
Published Jan. 7, 2020
Jason Auerbach is running for the open alderman seat in District 14, the Bay View position long held by Ald. Tony Zielinski. But while he's happy to talk about his ideas for Milwaukee, what really gets him fired up is the topic of monarch butterflies.
Published Dec. 2, 2019
Age had taken its toll on my alto sax, unplayed since 1992, so I brought it to Brass Bell in Glendale and asked if I could get it restored. A week later, the Conn sax was shiny and back in playing condition. Now the only thing that needs tuning up is me.
Published Nov. 26, 2019
In the 10 or so years that I've known Steve Palec - as a friend, associate and corporate real estate broker - I thought I knew all his stories. Nope, there are many more. His new memoir, "In Awe," drops on Dec. 2.
Published Nov. 18, 2019
Even though American Science & Surplus has its roots in Chicago - the first store opened there in 1937 - this amazing Milwaukee landmark has been in town, with its own identity, for 38 years and counting. "Each store has a little bit of its own personality," says Kim Stenglein, store manager at the Milwaukee location, 6901 W. Oklahoma Ave.
Published Oct. 28, 2019
Whether you're dining at the Shorewood location, or their "newer" spot in River Point shopping mall, Benji's is spectacularly consistent, and has been so for my whole life - and much longer than that.
Published Oct. 22, 2019
Lake Geneva native Joy Powers has taken a circuitous route to get back to Wisconsin. The "Lake Effect" producer and reporter worked in and out of radio, including a stint at WBEZ in Chicago, before joining the staff at 89.7 WUWM.
Published Oct. 15, 2019
It was 2013 the last time we told you about Live Band Karaoke. A lot has changed for the professional musicians who take regular old karaoke to the next level, not the least of which is a major upgrade in venues. This Friday, Live Band Karaoke will celebrate its 10th anniversary with a free party at the freshly renovated Paulie's Pub and Eatery, 8031 W. Greenfield Ave. in West Allis.
Published Oct. 15, 2019
Turning 40 is a major milestone. But instead of celebrating this midlife marker with black balloons or a pity party, Tiffany Ogle, the co-host of "The Morning Blend" is choosing to make a difference.
Published Sept. 27, 2019
A Madison IT consultant and his coworker recreated the 1977 "Smokey and The Bandit" beer run to and from Texarkana ... except with New Glarus' Spotted Cow. "When we went to work, we were like Santa Claus, handing out cases of beer," he says.
Published Sept. 23, 2019
Tim Dillard, former Brewers pitcher, occasional OnMilwaukee contributor, social media bon vivant, and all around funny guy, is heading back to Milwaukee Friday. This time, the Nashville Sounds reliever isn't playing baseball - he's coming here to unveil a new beer brewed in his honor.