In Dining

This delectable pizza - the recipe for which dates to the Palermo Villa days - will survive the closing of Divino. It will be on the menu at the new Tavolino, t

Owners vow new Tavolino restaurant will keep the Divino pizza recipe

If you're worried about the delicious Palermo Villa pizza disappearing when Divino Wine and Dine, 2315 N. Murray Ave., closes on Jan. 31, you can rest easy, say new owners Peter Dietrich and Derek Nackers.

"One of the conditions that we put into our agreement is that we were going to get the Palermo Villa recipe for the pizza," says Dietrich, "the sauce and the dough. We're not changing that."

You'll be happy to hear that when the duo – which has varied and extensive experience in the restaurant business in Milwaukee – reopens the restaurant as Tavolino (which means little table in Italian), a lot will feel familiar.

"The menu will be rotating seasonally," says Nackers. "It will probably change it three or four times a year, if not more. But we'll have a couple of (Divino) staples on there."

Among those items that will definitely remain are the popular arancini (meat-filled rice balls), the fried eggplant and the meatball appetizer.

The new menu will be more focused on modern Italian food and a bit less on the Italian-American classics, says Nackers, who has worked in many kitchens, including those at Tenuta's in Bay View, Tess on the East Side, Camille's in Cedarburg and Hinterland, as well as at restaurants owned by local groups Hospitality Democracy and Lowlands.

"I'd like to try to do something regional, not just pasta with everything," he says. "So we've got some regional stuff from northern Italy, from southern Italy. I like to focus on animals a lot. So, for our pork stew that we're doing I'm going to get whole pigs in and we're going to roast them in the oven and then butcher them.

"But with a couple of (Palermo Villa/Divino) classics thrown in. We want to pay a homage to some of the stuff that Dean's got going on that people tend to gravitate towards, like the eggplant ... the meatballs. Everybody needs a great meatball, right?"

Adds Dietrich, who was raised in the neighborhood and dined often at Palermo Villa with his family, "We are in the process of going through their menu and trying to see what will fit and what will work with what we want to bring to the table."

(PHOTO: Divino Facebook)

The Falluca family – which owns Palermo's frozen pizza in the Menomonee Valley – opened the restaurant in 1970. Eight years later, it was sold to Kathy Mirenda, who sold the business to her brother Dean Cannestra and Tina Conley in 2012 and they rebranded it as Divino, keeping the menu basically the same.

"The biggest thing for us is understanding the tradition within that building itself. We'll change cosmetically, we'll change the menu, but we still want it to be a neighborhood Italian restaurant. It's our belief that every neighborhood should have a great Italian restaurant and we want Tavolino to be that for the lower the East Side."

Entrees are expected to run between $15 and $30, with appetizers and salads in the $7-$15 range and desserts around $7-$8, says Nackers.

Dietrich says that the restaurant will get a new floor and there will be some other changes to the decor, but there will still be the separate bar area and the outdoor seating will remain, too.

(PHOTO: Divino Facebook)

The new owners hope to do a quick turnaround and have Tavolino ready to open by March 1, assuming all goes according to plan.

"If everything goes well with licensing and permits and whatnot," says Dietrich. "We're not making any structural changes to the space, so, I'm going to knock on wood and say I don't foresee any issues."


Post a comment / write a review.

Facebook Comments

Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of or its staff.