In Dining

Death by Chocolate, a flavor of the day at Georgie Porgie, has so many inclusions that it's like a sundae.

Every day is like sundae; happy National Chocolate Ice Cream Day

Today is National Chocolate Ice Cream Day, and even though it's Wednesday, it sure feels like a sundae. In fact, in Wisconsin, where ice cream and the related frozen custard are beloved, every day is like sundae.

"Most of our sundaes are made with vanilla custard," says Georgie Porgie's Gina Esch – reminding us of the reason that vanilla remains the top-selling flavor – a detail echoed by Cindi Sommer at Wautoma's classic Milty Wilty, too.

But I've never let that stop me, as a certified chocoholic, from tinkering with tradition. Everyone who follows my social media knows that soon after becoming a dusty road sundae fanatic, my addiction led me to innovate. I quickly created what I call the dusky road: hot fudge and malt powder (whipped cream optional) but with chocolate ice cream instead of vanilla as the base.

In that spirit, I asked a number of area ice cream stands – and custard places, too, since custard is ice cream (though, of course, not all ice cream is custard), albeit laced with egg yolks – about their richest, yummiest, ooey-gooeyist chocolate sundaes.

Nite Owl
830 E. Layton Ave.

"Our most famous sundae with chocolate is the Chocoholic," says second-generation owner Chris Roepke. "Two scoops of chocolate with hot fudge, whipped cream, nuts and a cherry."

Sounds amazing, to me. Is it Roepke's favorite?

"I'm the wrong guy to ask my favorite," he says. "I can't eat ice cream. Lactose intolerant. God's trick on me. I own an ice cream parlour but can't eat it."

Oh no. I hope he can eat burgers.

"Oh, yeah I can," he says.

Purple Door
205 S. 2nd St.

"Our most popular chocolate extravaganza sundae contains milk and dark chocolate ice cream with hot fudge, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate chips, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, and a malted milk ball," says Purple Door co-owner Lauren Schultz, who was guaranteed inclusion in this article as soon as she said "malted milk ball."

"My personal chocolate flavor is Malted Chocolate Chocolate Chunk," Schultz adds. "The addition of malt powder and the dark chocolate chunk pieces in the ice cream is heavenly." Yes, please.

Georgie Porgie
9555 S. Howell Ave., Oak Creek
5502 Washington Ave., Mount Pleasant

"Our best-selling chocolate custard flavor has to be Death by Chocolate," says Esch. "Chocolate custard, fudge, Oreos and chocolate flakes."

While it's not technically a sundae, it has so many inclusions that it looks, tastes and seems like a sundae, so I'll allow it. I asked Esch if it's her favorite.

"My favorite is actually an entry from last year's custard contest – the Tabby Kat," she says. "It's chocolate custard with caramel sauce and KitKat pieces. I love all things caramel and KitKat is one of my favorite candy bars. Put it together and this girl is in custard heaven!"

The Ruckus
4144 N. Oakland Ave., Shorewood

Up in Shorewood, according to The Ruckus' Scott Schwebel, you can get a sundae with, "fresh-spun dutch chocolate soft-serve, spiced fudge sauce with Troubadour chocolate chip crumble and churro."

But it's not actually a sundae, says Schwebel. "We call it a 'Saturdae' in our joint."

Milty Wilty
W7411 Wis. Hwy. 73, Wautoma

Milty Wilty owner Cindi Sommer, whose father opened the stand decades ago, says the turtle sundae is the most popular there, though with vanilla custard.

But, she adds, she also makes it with chocolate as the base, "When I need a double chocolate fix."

"I love hot fudge," Sommer adds. "Sometimes I make it a turtle, sometimes I add marshmallow or pecans or bananas or just have it by itself."


Post a comment / write a review.

Facebook Comments

Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of or its staff.