In Dining

These spendy collard greens caused quite the stir on social media. (PHOTO: Neiman Marcus)

How Neiman Marcus' collard greens blew up the damn internet

The internet was set ablaze in recent weeks as news spread that luxury retailer Neiman Marcus was selling trays of collard greens for $66.

Built for the holiday table, the fully cooked greens, "seasoned with just the right amount of spices and bacon," arrive packed in four 12-ounce trays and were advertised as enough to feed eight to 10 guests. With shipping, the frozen, ready-to-reheat dish sold for $81.50.

To offer some perspective, a dinner portion of prepared greens from Chic Cafe Downtown costs $3.50. And you can have them delivered to you – even eight to 10 servings – for an added cost of about $3. A family-sized portion of collard greens from Nino's Southern Sides in Shorewood is $11.49.

The costly dish isn't unusual for the retailer, which releases its Christmas Book each fall. The catalog is filled with myriad holiday gift ideas (mostly luxury items), including some particularly outrageously priced options, like a Cobalt Valkyrie-X Private Plane in rose gold for $1.5 million.

But the greens hit a nerve. Posts about the offering went viral, with many accusing the retailer of appropriating black culture, inciting a new hashtag: #gentrifiedgreens.

NPR covered it. The Boston Globe covered it. CBS News covered it. Here in the Midwest, Minneapolis-based soul food chefs were not amused. And neither were the folks at The Root.

"I can't even begin to imagine the conversation at the dinner table with my grandmother," said Yesha Callahan of The Root. "Do you know how many pounds of greens you could get for $66 at a grocery store? And who's cooking these greens? Is there some secret Neiman Marcus kitchen run by a grandmother or Paula Deen?"

They've also noted they plan to follow up with a review of the spendy greens, which gained even more traction this weekend when NM announced that the product was sold out.

Regardless of your perspective, the sheer interest generated by the NM offering is worthy of note. Because in the end, there's always an opportunity for conversation and understanding about why something as simple as collard greens strikes a chord for so many.

Is it right for someone to re-market a Southern soul food dish as a luxury item? Maybe more so, is it right for them to make a huge profit on food that owes its popularity largely to the the creativity of black Southerners?

Maybe none can speak to it more eloquently than food historian Michael Twitty, who wrote a piece about collard greens last year after Whole Foods published a recipe for the Southern staple without a reference to the dish's cultural history.

In the end, his message resonates:

''This food connects us to the globe. It connects us to Africa. It connects us to slavery, to freedom, to sharecropping, to migration, to triumph, to survival. It's a powerful symbol of our history, our social identity, and the cultural politics we negotiate our lives by [...] You don't have to be Jewish to eat Levy's Rye, and you don't have to be 'Colored' to love collards, but this is the key ... being culturally aware needs to be a value in our society – for all of us,'' he wrote.

It should give us all some food for thought.

Talkbacks

milROCKeeguy | Nov. 8, 2016 at 3:21 p.m. (report)

this is crazy to me. I'm on the internet and social media constantly, this is the first I'm seeing this. Did it blow it up? No. Did the changing color dress? Yes. That's blowing up the internet. Not a story you have to hunt, or is in your certain area of expertise.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
1 comment about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.

Facebook Comments

Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.